Retainers: Pros, Cons, and Costs for Each Type

2022-06-18 23:22:29 By : Ms. Jane Guo

Nancy LeBrun is an Emmy and Peabody award-winning writer and producer who has been writing about health and wellness for more than six years

Edmund Khoo, DDS, is board-certified in orthodontics and is a Diplomate of the American Board of Orthodontics.

Retainers keep your teeth in place after straightening with braces, aligners, or other devices. Oral healthcare providers, such as orthodontists, can also use retainers to improve your bite, move one or two teeth, or help you speak more clearly.

Here's a look at different types of retainers, their cost, and their pros and cons.

A retainer is a device that keeps your teeth in place after orthodontic treatment. Teeth tend to shift back toward their original position if they aren't kept in place while the bone hardens around them. Bones are living tissue and continue to change through our lives, and retainers can help keep your teeth aligned for many years.

Removable retainers are retainers that you take in and out yourself. Healthcare providers use them most often on the upper front teeth. Removable retainers are easy to slide in and out when you want, but you must keep track of them, use them as your provider recommends, and clean them regularly.

There are two types of removable retainers, and each has pros and cons.

Hawley retainers are what many people think of when they hear the word "retainer." They are one of the most common kinds of retainers and have been around for close to 100 years.

To create them, dental healthcare providers create a mold of your upper palate using hard plastic or acrylic and attach wires that hold your teeth in place. The plastic part used to be made to match the color of your palate, but now you can order it in various patterns and colors.

The other type of removable retainer is made of clear plastic or polyurethane .

To create them, your dental healthcare provider will make a mold of your teeth. Either their office or a lab will fill the mold with the clear material, which has been heated to soften it, so it conforms to the mold. A vacuum device pulls it tightly against the mold, so it makes a perfect replica of your teeth. When you wear it, the clear plastic is barely noticeable, if at all.

Here are some of the pros and cons of removable retainers.

Easy to put in and take out

Easy to maintain oral hygiene

Hawley retainer can be repaired

Hawley form is fairly durable

Clear retainers are not noticeable

Could be lost or misplaced

Clear retainers may tear or yellow over time

Clear retainers are not adjustable

Permanent retainers are placed by a dental healthcare provider and stay in place until removed by a professional. The dental healthcare provider custom fits a wire to the back of your teeth and glues or bonds it in place.

Permanent retainers are most commonly used for lower teeth. They can be a good option if you think you might not remember to use your removable retainer, but they can make it harder to keep your teeth clean.

Here are some of the pros and cons of permanent retainers.

Cannot be seen by others

You don't have to remember to put it in

Can be repaired or adjusted

Mold takes longer to make than removable retainer

Can be difficult to floss

Must be removed by an oral healthcare provider for adjustment if it's uncomfortable

Bond can loosen or break

Costs vary widely because the dental healthcare provider sets the cost of the retainer, and it can be different according to where you live, your insurance coverage, and other factors.

Some representative costs are below, including costs if they are lost, broken, or need adjustment.

Your dental healthcare provider will recommend the kind of retainer they feel is best for you or offer other options. They may suggest a combination of retainers: removable for the upper teeth and permanent for the lower teeth.

Remember that it will take about four to six months for the bone to harden around your teeth after orthodonture, but teeth can continue to shift as we age as our bones and other tissues change.

When you talk to your oral healthcare provider about types of retainers, think about which one may work best for you over the long haul. Remember the pros and cons of each type and what will best fit your lifestyle.

In the case of permanent retainers, it can be difficult to keep your teeth clean. However, floss threaders can get to areas you can't reach because of the wire. Water flossers are another option.

Consider, too, that if the wire of a permanent retainer breaks or bends, a oral healthcare provider will have to remove it to repair it. They can also cause irritation, but they can be adjusted if so.

Clear retainers are more fragile and more likely to need to be replaced.

If you want to make the most of the time and cost you put into straightening your teeth, you need a retainer. If you have only one or two teeth that need to be moved, a retainer rather than braces or an aligner might be able to address it.

If your tongue tends to move forward when you talk and makes your speech unclear, a retainer can realign your teeth slightly so that you can articulate more clearly.

Retainers help keep your teeth in position after orthodontic treatment, like teeth straightening.

Retainers fall into two categories: removable and permanent. Removable retainers can be made with a mold of your upper palate and wires or with a clear material that is not very visible but is more delicate. Permanent retainers are fitted and placed by your dental healthcare provider, who can remove them if necessary.

All retainers have their pros and cons, so consider cost, maintenance, ease of use, durability, and visibility preference when discussing retainers with your dental healthcare provider.

If you wore braces or clear aligners, you've probably put a lot of time and money into getting your teeth where you want them. It's a great feeling to finally see the results, so it's worth the commitment to wear your retainer as long as recommended or beyond. Talk to your dental healthcare provider about which retainer option is the best for you.

Permanent or Hawley wire retainers tend to last longer than clear molded retainers. In part, it depends on how well you take care of them. The clear retainers are the most delicate and could last up to three years. A Hawley retainer can last up to 10 years. A permanent retainer can last for up to 20 years.

Retainers don't straighten your teeth; they keep them in place after your dental healthcare provider uses braces or aligners to make them straighter. Some clear aligners look very similar to retainers, but a retainer can also make minor adjustments if only a few teeth need to be moved slightly.

Oral healthcare providers have different recommendations for how long you should wear your retainer. It will take months for the bone to harden around the newly positioned teeth, and they can still move after that. Some people wear their retainers at night indefinitely. Follow your dental healthcare provider's instructions for how long to wear a retainer for best results.

If you have a permanent retainer, try a floss threader to work around the wire. Water flossers can also work well, though they are a bit more of an investment. They remove debris with a high-pressure stream of water. Once you get the hang of it, they can work very well.

Sign up for our Health Tip of the Day newsletter, and receive daily tips that will help you live your healthiest life.

Thank you, {{form.email}}, for signing up.

There was an error. Please try again.

Nemours Kids Health. The reality of retainers.

Stanford Children's Health. Retainers keep teeth from shifting.

American Association of Orthodontists. Will I need to wear retainers after treatment?

Ramazanzadeh B, Ahrari, Zahra-Sadat Z. The retention characteristics of Hawley and vacuum-formed retainers with different retention protocols. J Clin Exp Dent. 2018;10(3):e224-231. doi:10.4317/jced.54511

Authority Dental. What is the difference between permanent, Hawley and clear retainer?

Orthodontics Australia. Teeth shifting: signs, causes, prevention and treatment.

Johnston CD, Littlewood SJ. Retention in orthodontics. Br Dent J. 2015;218(3):119-122. doi:10.1038/sj.bdj.2015.47

Thank you, {{form.email}}, for signing up.

There was an error. Please try again.